As discussed in an earlier JTA Law Insight https://jtalaw.com.au/nsw-strata-law-update-new-6-year-limitation-period/, the NSW District Court’s decision in John Goubran & Associates Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan 57150 [2026] NSWDC 9 considered the effect of the extended limitation period for section 106(6) claims in NSW.
However, the circumstances of the dispute highlight a broader issue for insurers, owners corporations and strata managers: the importance of addressing building defects before they develop into significant losses.
Small Building Issues Can Become Large Claims
Anyone involved in strata insurance is familiar with the recurring themes. A leaking roof. Failed waterproofing. Cracked balcony tiling. Deteriorating sealants around windows.
Rarely do these issues begin as major losses.
More often, they start as relatively minor maintenance items that worsen over time because investigations are delayed, repairs are deferred or responsibility is disputed.
By the time the issue reaches insurers, solicitors or tribunals, the damage has often spread well beyond the original defect. What might once have been a straightforward repair can become a claim involving multiple lots, loss of rent, expert evidence and substantial rectification costs.
Why Pro-active Maintenance Matters to Insurers
Owners corporations and body corporates often view maintenance and insurance as separate issues. In practice, they are closely connected.
From an underwriting perspective, a building with a history of unresolved water ingress, recurring defects or deferred maintenance presents a very different risk to a building that is actively maintained and professionally managed.
Regular inspections, preventative maintenance programs and prompt repairs not only reduce the likelihood of damage occurring, but can also help prevent isolated issues from developing into larger and more expensive claims.
Managing Risk Before a Claim Arises
For committees and strata managers, the lesson is straightforward: treat maintenance as a risk-management exercise rather than simply a budget item.
While insurance premiums are influenced by a range of factors, the condition of the building and the approach taken to maintenance are among matters that owners corporations and body corporates can directly influence.
Early investigation of issues, timely repairs and proper record keeping can:
- reduce the likelihood of claims by lot owners;
- minimise the extent of property damage;
- assist insurers in assessing and responding to claims; and
- contribute to a better long-term risk profile for the building.
Insurance plays an important role when losses occur, but it should not be viewed as a substitute for maintaining and repairing common property. The best outcome for insurers, owners corporations and lot owners alike is the early identification and rectification of defects before they result in significant damage, disputes or claims.

